A FEW THINGS YOU’LL WANT TO KNOW
What's the difference between this and the tomato version?
Honestly, it comes down to how you're feeling on the day. Every Lebanese household has their own version of this stew, and mine swings between the two depending on my mood — some days I want that richer, slightly tangy tomato base, other days I want the broth to stay light and let the lamb and broad beans speak for themselves. Same ingredients, same method either way, just a different version of comfort depending on what you're after.
Can I use a different cut of lamb instead of lamb backstrap?
Lamb backstrap is what makes this version work the way it does — it's naturally so tender that it doesn't need any pre-cooking, which is why it can go into the pot together with the broad beans from the start. If you'd like to use a cheaper cut instead, that's completely fine, but you'll need to give the lamb a head start. Sauté your onion, brown the lamb, then pour in the water and simmer on low-medium for about 25 minutes until the lamb starts to turn tender, before adding your broad beans and cooking everything together for a further 20 to 25 minutes.
Will the broth be thin without the tomato?
It's meant to be more of a light broth than a thick stew. The beans and lamb still thicken it slightly as everything cooks down together.
Can I add tomato back in if I change my mind partway through?
Yes — just stir a can of crushed tomatoes in during Step 3 and pull the added water back down to 4 cups.
Can I freeze this stew?
Yes, it freezes really well. Cool it completely before freezing in an airtight container, then thaw in the fridge overnight and reheat gently on the stove.
When is broad bean season?
Here in Australia, broad beans are a spring vegetable, so you'll find the best ones from around September through to November. If you're in the Northern Hemisphere, look for them earlier in the year, from around April through to June. Either way, that's when they're at their most tender and sweetest, so it's the time I always stock up and make this stew.
Do I really need to de-string the broad beans?
Yes, every time. I tried skipping it once years ago when I was short on time and thought I'd get away with it — I didn't. You end up with tough, stringy bits running through every bite, and it ruins the whole dish. It only takes a few extra minutes and it's genuinely worth it.
Why do the cut broad beans go into a bowl of water?
This keeps them bright green while you finish prepping the rest. Once they're cut and left sitting out, they start to discolour quite quickly, so a bowl of water keeps them looking fresh until they go into the pot.
Can I just add the garlic in with the onions instead of frying it separately at the end?
Of course — there's no one right way to do this, and it really comes down to how you feel like making it on the day. I like frying the garlic on its own at the end this time because without the tomato in this version, I want that garlic flavour to really come through and sit on top of the stew rather than melt into the background. But if you'd rather keep things simple, go ahead and add the garlic in with the onions at the start, and skip that last step altogether.